The 5th Judge - American Idol's Top 20 Hits & Misses

I’m a fan of music; ANY music. I’ll listen to anything and give anything a chance. Most of the time, I’ll like what I hear. I’ve seen every single Idol season from beginning to end and have paid attention religiously. So, I’m no Simon Cowell, but I am about as well-rounded musically as they come. I’ll go through each performance after it airs via the DVR. I’ll fast-forward through the judge’s comments as to avoid being swayed, give a little feedback, rate it on a scale of 1-10, possibly mention what I’d like to see that person sing next week, and list the hits, misses, and predictions of who America will send packing at the end. With that said, here’s what I saw on this weeks’ Top 20 Edition of American Idol.